Hamlin, NY Fatal Crash – The Greece, New York community is mourning a devastating loss following a fatal two-vehicle crash at the intersection of West Ridge Road and Elmgrove Road. The accident, which occurred around 1 p.m. on January 17, has claimed the lives of three individuals, including Riesen Kimmerly, 25, and her boyfriend Tyler Underwood, 28, both of Hamlin, New York.

According to the Greece Police Department, Kimmerly was driving a vehicle that was stopped at a red light when it was rear-ended by a westbound pickup truck driven by 42-year-old Craig Cavallaro of Hilton. Tragically, Cavallaro was pronounced dead at the scene. Kimmerly and Underwood were immediately transported to Strong Memorial Hospital with severe injuries.
Riesen Kimmerly succumbed to her injuries on January 17, as confirmed in her obituary released on Saturday. Her boyfriend, Tyler Underwood, who was a passenger in the vehicle, passed away five days later on January 22. The couple’s puppy, who was also in the vehicle at the time of the crash, did not survive the collision.
Family members shared that both Kimmerly and Underwood suffered traumatic head injuries and multiple broken bones. Kimmerly underwent surgery to address a collapsed lung and a brain bleed sustained in the crash. The depth of the tragedy has left family, friends, and the local community grieving the sudden loss of two young lives.
The Greece Police Department stated that the investigation into the accident remains ongoing. Authorities continue to gather details about the sequence of events that led to the collision. “The Greece Police Department extends its deepest condolences to the families, friends, and loved ones of those who tragically lost their lives in this incident during this incredibly difficult time,” the department said in a news release.
In response to the tragedy, an online fundraiser has been established to support the victims’ families during this difficult period. The community has shown an outpouring of support, with neighbors and friends expressing shock and sorrow over the fatal incident.
This devastating accident highlights the importance of road safety and awareness, particularly in busy intersections. Residents are urged to remain vigilant and adhere to traffic regulations to prevent similar tragedies in the future.